Free Exercise...Or Force?
Login   Comment   Save article   Message   Print   TheCheers BUDDY   
Hmm... / Opinion

By Susan Levine, Columnist






The Cheers magazine is looking for creative people to join our forces. We are looking for

  • Writers
  • Special topic/genre writers
  • On-call theme writers
  • Editors
  • Project leaders

    Sounds interesting?
    Click here for more info.










  • More from author
    -  The Titanic Effect...And The Criminal Justice System
    -  Striking Back At Terrorism By Extortion
    -  The New American Witch Hunt
    -  Presumption of Innocence Denied In Virginia
    -  A Supreme Court For the Religious Right? Not If We Can Prevent It!

    See news about
    There will be no page refresh, so check it out.
     


    Objection #1

    "We should be free to opt out of killing humans at any stage of development," Ms Brauer stated in an article that appeared in the April 8, 2005 issue of the Christian Science Monitor. Ms Brauer’s position is that emergency and regular oral contraceptives work by inhibiting ovulation, fertilization, or implantation. While most medical professionals define pregnancy as beginning with implantation in the uterus, she and others consider a fertilized egg - even before implantation - to be human. It is only a belief, however, and does not give her or Pharmacists For Life the right to force it onto another person by refusing to fill her contraceptive prescription.

    Objection #2

    "Forced referral is stupid," Brauer bluntly stated in an Associated Press report on September 16, 2004. "If we’re not going to kill a human being, we’re not going to help the customer go do it somewhere else." She insists pro-life pharmacists have the right to refuse dispensing contraceptive prescriptions themselves, and can also opt out of referring customers elsewhere or transferring prescriptions.

    Once again, Brauer has decided that her religious beliefs and those of Catholics or Christians opposed to contraception are superior to the legal right of every customer to obtain the contraceptive prescribed by her doctor. The fact that the law states otherwise is irrelevant, as she honestly believes her opinions are "divine law" and should be honored no matter what. Her underlying message is obvious to anyone who can read: "Screw the law, it doesn’t apply to me."

    Objection #3

    Pro-life pharmacists insist they shouldn’t have to fill prescriptions for contraceptives due to moral or religious beliefs. Using this "logic" a sales clerk at a package store shouldn’t have to sell whiskey to a customer because she has personal objections to hard liquor. Using this "logic" any employee should be exempt from performing parts of a job she doesn’t like. That argument is unlikely to fly with employers. If an employee is accepting money for working at a particular establishment, it is that person’s responsibility to perform all parts of the job that are expected.

    In the case of a pharmacist, a large part of the job is filling prescriptions written by doctors for customers. A pharmacist who has problems dispensing prescriptions for contraceptives due to religious conflicts has two options. He can either seek employment in a store that doesn’t stock contraceptives at all or change career. Nobody is forcing a person to stay at a job where he or she is unhappy with the work. Any pharmacist, however, who takes a job at a store location selling contraceptives along with other inventory had better be ready to comply with the duties of the job or risk losing it.

    Comstock Revisited?

    It is alarming enough that reports of pharmacy refusals of this nature are increasing. It is even worse that a growing number of pharmacy owners and managers are supporting employees who claim "right of conscience" in refusing to fill contraceptive prescriptions. It raises a disturbing question in some of our minds. Chiefly, are the notorious and dreaded Comstock laws now being brought in through the back door when we thought they’d been kicked out the front?

    The creator of the original anti-birth control statutes was Anthony Comstock. Born in Connecticut, one of the most repressive states where contraception was concerned, he moved to New York City after serving in the Civil War. As a devout Christian, Comstock was appalled by what he saw in the streets of the city. According to him, the town was full of prostitutes and pornography. In the late 1860's, he began supplying information to the police for raids on sex trade merchants and rose to prominence with his "anti-obscenity" cause. In addition to cracking down on the sex trade, Comstock soon began targeting the contraceptive industry. He was positive that availability of contraception alone produced lust and lewdness.

    Brauer and Comstock, although more than a century apart, seem to have a disturbing view in common. Each held the conviction that personal religious beliefs gave them a special right to force their views onto American citizens. In their minds, it didn’t matter that some hold different views regarding sex and contraception. Only "their" opinions are important. In the past, few politicians, if any, stood up to Comstock and told him he had no right to force his religious beliefs onto Americans.

    Happily, things have changed. Governor Rod Blagojevich of Illinois publicly took a stand in April 2005 and filed an emergency law requiring pharmacists to fill contraceptive prescriptions without delay. Women across the nation salute him for this courageous action and hope more governors in others in all fifty states will follow suit. It is necessary for all Governors, Senators and Congressmen to do the same, before religious policy-makers succeed in turning this "conscience clause" into law. If that happens, we will truly be back in the Dark Ages of back-alley abortions, due to the refusal of these moralistic pharmacists to provide the contraception written for them by their doctors, and may remain there for many years to come.




    AUTHOR: Susan Levine

    TAGS: Opinion                           

    BOOKMARK: Digg it  |  Add to Del.ICIO  |  Add to FARK  

    ACTIONS: Comment   Save   Print   Register free acount   



    sara




    sara says on 2005-10-01 13:41:51 about Force
    Excellent article! Fully worth a full beer. Your writing style is right on the mark and your arguments are lucid, cogent, and persuasive. You MUST have been on the debate team in years past. If not, they missed a pearl.

    I am a Catholic and absolutely agree with your argument. It is not up to us to push our values and beliefs on others. Nor do I believe pharmacists have any right to deny services based on religous beliefs. I agree, find a store that suits you or get out of the business.

    Well done!






    Lue




    Lue says on 2005-09-30 00:23:31 about Force?
    This is an impressive and informative article.
    Thanks for the education. I believe no man should tell a woman what to do, or not do,
    with her body! I hope you get a hndred thousand hits on this!









    Post Comment

     
     Your nickname
     
     About what
     
     Your comment
     




    ADVERTISEMENTS
    Anxiety - Anxiety, Depression and ADHD related information.


    DUI Lawyer - find the right attorney nationwide | vasectomy reversal - The operating suite at MMHC was designed solely for the performance of microsurgical vasectomy reversals. | 16mm Film to DVD | Comcast promotional offers - . | erase bad credit | PEO Companies - | Steel Building | Frigidaire parts

    The Cheers magazine: About us | Contact us | The Cheers Story | Advertising
    Work with The Cheers: Writers guide | Write for us | Writer application | Reporter application | Affiliates
    The Cheers feeds: Free article feeds | Free news feeds
    The Cheers: Brand Lady (sister magazine) | Terms and conditions | Privacy policy | Sponsoring | Sitemap
    Watch: Watch movies online | Watch free tv online | Watch heroes online
    Trade: Virtual stock market | Fantasy investing competitions | Free day trading tips
    Learn: Business videos online | Business networking | Business strategies | Business ideas
      Write for us:  Become a writer    Become a reporter Latest news: New Book Published