Free Exercise...Or Force?
Login   Comment   Save article   Message   Print   TheCheers BUDDY   
Hmm... / Opinion

By Susan Levine, Columnist


R
eligious conservatives argue their moral beliefs against contraception give pro-life pharmacists the right to refuse dispensing prescriptions for various contraceptive methods.


The Cheers magazine
is looking for
new contributors

Play Online Poker





More from author
-  The Titanic Effect...And The Criminal Justice System
-  Striking Back At Terrorism By Extortion
-  The New American Witch Hunt
-  Presumption of Innocence Denied In Virginia
-  A Supreme Court For the Religious Right? Not If We Can Prevent It!

See news about
There will be no page refresh, so check it out.
 
  Religious conservatives argue their moral beliefs against contraception give pro-life pharmacists the right to refuse dispensing prescriptions for various contraceptive methods. Pro-choice advocates argue personal convictions, whatever they may be, do not give these pharmacists the right to withhold patient medications. It has been unclear which side will triumph after years of active debate. One question, however, has been overlooked and must be addressed now: When did the right to free exercise of religion become the right to force it?

  To get our answer, let’s look at the First Amendment. The relevant section deals specifically with religion and government. "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof." Although written over two hundred years ago, the language isn’t that hard to understand. Simply put, it says that Congress can’t force a state or national religion onto Americans, nor can it prohibit them the right to free exercise of religion.

This statement is so simple there shouldn’t be any doubt as to its meaning or intent. Yet pharmacists who insist it is their right to refuse filling prescriptions for contraceptives for religious or "moral" reasons are missing the obvious. Specifically, that "free exercise of religion" stops with each individual. When a pro-life pharmacist says he will not fill contraceptive prescriptions because his religion doesn’t permit it, he has crossed the line. He is no longer exercising his religion for himself but is establishing through force his religious doctrine on the customer. If Congress isn’t allowed to establish a religion nor religious doctrine for a state or country, it cannot be legally possible for one individual to force his or her religion onto another.

Karen L. Brauer, President of Pharmacists For Life, states pro-life pharmacists have a "right of conscience". She and others argue that this right or "conscience clause" permits them to do two things: opt out of filling prescriptions for contraceptives, and refuse passing on the slip for dispensing by another pharmacist. Brauer makes several arguments why their perceived right trumps that of the customer who brings in a prescription for contraceptives. We need to look at the objections presented, and answer each one individually.



Continued On Next Page (contraceptive, Page 2) ...


AUTHOR: Susan Levine

TAGS: Opinion                           

BOOKMARK: Digg it  |  Add to Del.ICIO  |  Add to FARK  

ACTIONS: Comment   Save   Print   Register free acount   



sara




sara says on 2005-10-01 13:41:51 about Force
Excellent article! Fully worth a full beer. Your writing style is right on the mark and your arguments are lucid, cogent, and persuasive. You MUST have been on the debate team in years past. If not, they missed a pearl.

I am a Catholic and absolutely agree with your argument. It is not up to us to push our values and beliefs on others. Nor do I believe pharmacists have any right to deny services based on religous beliefs. I agree, find a store that suits you or get out of the business.

Well done!






Lue




Lue says on 2005-09-30 00:23:31 about Force?
This is an impressive and informative article.
Thanks for the education. I believe no man should tell a woman what to do, or not do,
with her body! I hope you get a hndred thousand hits on this!









Post Comment

 
 Your nickname
 
 About what
 
 Your comment
 




ADVERTISEMENTS
Anxiety - Anxiety, Depression and ADHD related information.


DUI Lawyer - find the right attorney nationwide | vasectomy reversal - Up to 95 percent vasectomy reversal success rate. | Convert 8mm Film to DVD | Comcast promotional offers - . | erase bad credit | Staff Leasing - | Steel Building | Frigidaire parts

The Cheers magazine: About us | Contact us | The Cheers Story | Advertising
Work with The Cheers: Writers guide | Write for us | Writer application | Reporter application | Affiliates
The Cheers feeds: Free article feeds | Free news feeds
The Cheers: Brand Lady (sister magazine) | Terms and conditions | Privacy policy | Sponsoring | Sitemap
Watch: Watch movies online | Watch free tv online | Watch heroes online
Trade: Virtual stock market | Fantasy investing competitions | Free day trading tips
Learn: Business videos online | Business networking | Business strategies | Business ideas
  Write for us:  Become a writer    Become a reporter Latest news: Are you so sure, Mr Tan Kin Lian