If
mental health professionals find problems with my ideas, senior members
of the various Twelve Step groups may well join them in the complaint
department because I suggest, in the pages to follow, some re-wording
of those basic Twelve Steps.
Times
and people have changed in the seventy years or so since William Wilson
wrote his program for recovery in Alcoholics Anonymous. Our courts have
increasingly classified Alcoholics Anonymous, and, by extension, all
similar Twelve Step programs, as religious organizations. The words God and Higher Power
appear in the steps for recovery, and meetings often begin and/or end
with group prayer. The problem with this arises when professional
treatment programs order their patients to attend such groups as a part
of treatment. It amounts, in the eyes of the law, to enforced religious
attendance, and the courts have ruled in favor of those who filed
complaints.
We
may not like what the federal courts decide, but it is the law.
Learning to obey and respect the law, it seems to me, is fundamental to
personality development and to the recovery of normal living. In the United States,
we practice the separation of church and state and so, by extension, we
cannot use government money to force religious participation.
Fortunately, I think there is a good way out of this problem.
Religion
is, of course, a matter of personal choice. And I do not agree with
treatment programs that enforce attendance in any particular self-help
group program as a part of their treatment, whether or not is contains
religious elements. Very often, paid professional addictions counselors
attend community groups along with patients and run the meetings. This,
of course, is in violation of the traditions of Alcoholics Anonymous as
we shall see later. Good treatment would involve suggested
exposure to, and study of, any and all self-help programs offered in
the community. Recovering addicts cannot learn to make good choices if
choice is taken from their hands by the treatment staff.
As
far a traditional A.A. meetings go, if someone is abstaining and is
comfortable in their recovery, there is probably little point in
changing what works for them. As senior members of self-help groups
know, however, some newcomers take a long time to accept parts of the
recovery program. Most newcomers, in fact, leave after a few meetings;
the retention rate in Twelve Step groups is low, and this is sad
because there really is not much long-term help available outside of
these Twelve Step groups. Although the dropout rate is high, many new
members eventually return. Growth and understanding take time to
develop. Professional treatment programs last only for a matter of days
or weeks, and then the person is alone once more. Professional
treatment is very expensive. The self-help groups will always be there,
however, and they are free.
It
has been my impression that even if a person leaves a Twelve Step group
after a short time, he or she has learned something of importance,
perhaps just a thought or bit of information that may surface months or
years later to lead them on to a better abstinence and back to the
group. We have no way of knowing the long-term benefits of attending
even a few meetings, but something, I think, is always learned and
retained.
There
is a tendency among mental health professionals to ignore the Twelve
Step recovery programs. They may leave clients in the hands of
recovering peer counselors who themselves are abstaining addicts paid
for their work. Professional treatment sometimes does not even
recommend or encourage attendance at meetings of any of the various
groups that have the word anonymous in their names. Some mental
health professionals, in fact, warn clients to avoid self-help groups
that offer any kind of spiritual education. Ethically, the professional
therapist cannot force attendance in self-help groups although in the
past our legal system sometimes has done so as a condition of parole or
probation, but we should at least encourage clients to try them.
Professional
psychotherapy is restricted by financial resources, but many addicts
see psychotherapy as more noble or perhaps more effective than
long-term participation in any of the groups of anonymous fellow
sufferers. In my opinion, it is a disservice to honor the client’s
belief that he or she is too good or too complicated for self-help
groups. It is a disservice to offer the hope that some relatively quick
therapeutic magic can eliminate a serious addiction. Obviously, once
treatment is finished, once the bills are paid, the client is again
alone to cope as best he or she can. Experience shows that without the
continuing compassionate care of groups such as Alcoholics Anonymous or
Overeaters Anonymous, the chances of good abstinence and improved
quality of life are significantly reduced.
[BB]
In
many cases, when professionals sell treatment for the various addictive
disorders, they have little to offer beyond a few psychological tests,
perhaps a captive meeting of Alcoholics Anonymous, and whatever number
of group therapy sessions health insurance plans are willing to
subsidize. A rare treatment program here and there bothers to collect
and publish its success rate where success is defined in terms of
abstinence and improved quality of life. Psychotherapy is still very
much an act of faith when it is offered by itself as a treatment for
addiction.
The
Anonymous groups are free, and they will be there long after therapy is
over. They offer in their philosophy certain profound and necessary
conditions for normal living. Related groups for loved ones of the
addict offer help and support to others in the addict’s life through
the practice of the same value system.
One
advantage of a well-trained doctoral level professional should be a
broad view of the individual client, and of all the other possible
problems that may be discovered. On the other hand, members of Twelve
Step groups have a great depth of understanding in the particular
problem with which they deal. It would be my preference to see
professional treatment as an auxiliary to Twelve Step or other kinds of
community groups, not the other way around. In my estimation, only
about twenty percent of addicts have problems that require professional
attention, the rest in some way are able to cure themselves or use the
folk psychology of recovery groups such as Alcoholics Anonymous.
Many
psychological problems for which professional treatment might be
helpful seem to emerge later in abstinence; frequently an attempt at
psychotherapy is ineffective in the early days of sobriety. The first
step is to acquire some degree of emotional stability through sobriety
or abstinence, a stability that includes a resolution to do whatever is
required to keep and improve the quality of abstinence. More than
abstinence, sobriety is a state of mind that can be learned, practiced
and taught to others. This is a state of mind that all addicts must
learn. I use sobriety and sober to refer to a mature state of mind as much as to non-intoxication.
The
first priority is always to stop using and, sadly, many therapists
still try to work with clients who are practicing an addiction when
they should suggest the client attend a recovery self-help group and
have a medical detoxification program if needed.
It
is my strong opinion, then, based on experience with addictive disorder
clients, that professional treatment should support and compliment a
Twelve Step Program or other long term community self-help program.
Professional therapy is not, however; a replacement for it. So, I have
a problem: how do I encourage attendance in what the courts have
decided is a religious organization, attendance that I think is often
essential in long term abstinence?
The
legal system is not alone in questioning the religious content of
Twelve Step programs. Some newcomers in the Twelve Step anonymous
groups are put off by prayer and the use of words like God and Higher
Power. My goal here is to analyze the ideas contained in the Twelve
Steps in terms of their practical importance to recovery from any
addiction, not to encourage any kind of religious practice. We must,
beyond this, find ways to use Twelve Step philosophy without giving
even the appearance of religiosity if we expect the broad support of
the professional community and the legal system.
Some will say this is impossible, but please keep an open mind and bear with me.
[BB]
My
ambition is to improve the quality of life on this earth. I take no
position on questions of religious belief and leave the reader to
formulate what, if any, of such beliefs seem appropriate and helpful for themselves but not for others. Religious
elements in any Twelve Step program should, I believe, be considered as
personal and private options, never as essential and required elements.
This issue, then, is the one on which some readers may take offense. I
beg their tolerance for the time being. In rejecting religious aspects
of recovery I am not rejecting their value in society or the person who
may hold those ideas.
Those
who wish to incorporate religious values and beliefs into their
recovery programs should certainly be free to do so while respecting
the right and ability of non-believers to profit from the basic
concepts contained in the Twelve Steps. Tolerance of diverse religious
beliefs is essential, and would include, I think, avoiding persuasive
attempts to change the religious beliefs of others when such efforts
properly belong in the domain of religion itself. In other words,
abstinence from addiction and the repair of the damage done by it are
the essential areas of focus. Everything else is arbitrary and
optional. No matter how important and valuable you have found your
religion to be, I suggest you leave it at home and in the church,
temple or mosque when you attend a public self-help group.
All
that said, some sort of conversion experience to new values, not to
mystical religion, is a significant feature in most abstinence and
recovery stories. The phenomenon of the spiritual experience will be discussed in columns to follow. The word spiritual is here used in a non-religious sense of the human spirit,
and includes motivation, drive, insight or enlightenment. Nothing,
however, should deter the individual from privately adding religion to
their lives if they wish, but there is no substitute for a new way of
acting and thinking here, today, in this material world of ours. Just
putting in the concept of God and saying a few prayers cannot
substitute for real personal growth and change. On the other hand, no
obstacle, not even in the wording of the Steps themselves, should be
placed in the path of an agnostic who needs the concepts and values
offered in the Twelve Steps yet cannot honestly be comfortable with
religion.
The admonition to carry the message
does no refer to the religious tradition of teaching the insights of
religion in the non-religious. As used in A.A., it means to carry the
message of sobriety and recovery. It is a message of optimism for a
better life now, in this world, not a promise of a place in Heaven.
Trained as a research psychologist at the University of Pittsburgh, Dr.Taber spent eight years teaching at Case Western Reserve University before entering full time work in clinical psychology. He is best known for his work with problem gamblers, but he also specialized with drug and alcoholism clients while at Veterans Administration hospitals in Ohio, Nevada and Oregon. He has written extensively on addictionology and related topics. Now retired, Taber continues his special interest in writing directly for the recovering addict.
Politics
Factzone: The truth about Kim Jong Il
Kim Jong Il, the leader of the free world, has decided to move on to more fertile grounds, leaving with us just the memories of 8-color rainbows, singing Korean women and couple of nuclear weapons. But who was this man whose next ambition would have been to get the next Nobel Peace prize? Here are just a few facts you should know about.
more
Top 5 Conspiracy Theories Related to John F. Kennedy's Assassination
26.Aug 2011
Since just after the assassination of John F. Kennedy, conspiracy theories abou...read
ISRAEL KEEPING GHADDAFI AFLOAT
10.Mar 2011
...read
Glen Beck Is NOT the Anti-Christ!
10.Mar 2011
Hurtful and fiery rhetoric is now media’s default setting! This slippery and m...read
Recipe for A REVOLUTION! (10 easy steps - try not to get burned!)
28.Feb 2011
Rebellion is cooking in the air. People are mad as hell, and not going to take...read
Opinion
World governments charged with criminal negligence (in response to Megaupload case)
EARTH (thecheers.org) - Federal authorities of the universe have charged the governments of all the countries in the world as well as the operators actually in power in these countries with operating a criminal enterprise, the Galaxy warriors announced Today.
more
The Great OSCARS 2011 – or so it would seem
5.Mar 2011
So, how exciting......a morning off, the Academy Awards. I wish I could say the...read
Top 7 Expensive Bordellos. Prostitution: Shakedown, Tier Down, and Priced Out
31.Jan 2011
According to a report of the Washington DC-based US Department of State, The Ph...read
The Great Secret and Reason for the JFK Assassination
11.Oct 2010
The great question is why the great secret? On June 4 1963, President Kennedy s...read
Don't Do it! The 3 Worst Times to Get Tattoos
4.Oct 2010
As a general rule, tattoos gotten after 2 am are a bad idea. But in a bigger pi...read
|
Travel
Travel Warning 13 September 2010 - DO NOT TRAVEL TO IRAN
13.Sep 2010
TRAVELWISE has been watching the situation in Iran for some months in relation ...read
more
TRAVELWISE TRAVEL ADVISORY 5th June 2010. DO NOT TRAVEL TO ISRAEL.
5.Jun 2010
Given the recent incident whereby the Israeli intelligence agency, Mossad, used...read
TRAVELWISE. 16 APRIL 2010. EUROPEAN TRAVEL ALTERNATIVES
16.Apr 2010
Travelwise issues the following advice in relation to cancelled flights to, fro...read
TRAVELWISE 6 APRIL 2010. AUSTRALIAN AIR TRAVEL. THE BEST WAYS TO TRAVEL BY AIR IN AUSTRALIA.
5.Apr 2010
Regular readers might have seen and read the various advisory and no-fly notice...read
TRAVELWISE 2 APRIL 2010. QANTAS.
2.Apr 2010
Some concerns have been raised in relation to some of the maintenance practices...read
No Payoff From the Playoffs
$16.50 will Get Anyone in the Hall Mr McGwire
Stupid Athlete Tricks
Think Big! Think the World's Largest International Trade Show
Top 9 cool laptop accessories for laptop geeks
Twittering: I'm not that interesting
Cheers
|
|
|
|
|
|
Fransway says on 2006-06-07 01:54:29 about "Addictions Anonymous, 2: Self-help, Professionals And The Role of Religion"
The writer's opinions are clearly based on his experiences in 12 step faith healing groups rather than facts. There’s no proof that these groups work any better than self recovery. There’s no proof that folks go in and out of the revolving door of meetings learn anything from them, except, of course, the foolish fallacy that an addict has a disease and will never recover but only get worse and worse until they OD or die of liver disease, and that the best method of being saved is attend 12-step meetings and practice their religious rituals.
12-step groups are not in any way superior to other method of quitting an addition, including self recovery. Please prove why the U.S. government has to send people who get in trouble with the law due to drinking or drugs to *any* group.
If addiction is a disease, why are there no doctors in most recovery houses and detoxes? If addicts and alcoholics are sick, where is the proof that putting them all together in one place without a doctor is conductive to getting well?
As far as treatment goes, there’s really no such thing, except by a licensed, qualified MDs who are NOT members of a step groups. Would you take your psychological problems to be treated by a Scientologist? No? Then why should people that may or may not have an addiction problem be treated by A.A. and N.A. members?
I think that you could send all the addictions professionals in a leaky rocket ship to Mars, and the world would be a better place. But I’m glad at least some of these professionals have taken to steering clients away from the step groups. The groups have a long history of being havens for bullies and predators, as well as idiots who urge mentally ill members to go off their medications—a practice that has resulted in countless deaths and suicides.
Here's one more fact for you. Twelve step groups began as unabashed faith healing organizations. The groups cling to their history and their traditions. They won't change, and they don't have to change just to satisfy the courts’ problems with the first amendment.
From the beginning, most of the groups never wanted criminals from the courts coming to meetings to get their court slips signed. To ask them to change the wordings of the steps and other religious rituals so the courts can legally send their criminals to step groups to be “fixed” is extremely arrogant. The courts simply have to stop sending criminals to faith healing groups. State & county governments have to stop funding any recovery house or and detox that doesn’t have medical doctors on duty. Insurance companies need to stop paying for addiction “treatment” that doesn’t involve a doctor.
Let people who are dangerous when drinking and using either do their jail terms, or, if they have to be sent somewhere, to damage control classes, where they can learn to cut down on criminal behavior if they do drink and use—such turning over car keys and taking taxis to gad about, or to have their liquor delivered, or to stop drinking in bars if that’s where they get into trouble.
Studies show that most "addicts" who quit or cut down, eventually do so all by themselves, without the help of 12 step groups.
Rebecca Fransway
|
|
|
|
|
|
