Gay Marriage and the Politics of Division
Login   Comment   Save article   Message   Print   TheCheers BUDDY   
Hmm... / Opinion

By Rich Bowden(UNV), Journalist






The Cheers magazine is looking for creative people to join our forces. We are looking for

  • Writers
  • Special topic/genre writers
  • On-call theme writers
  • Editors
  • Project leaders

    Sounds interesting?
    Click here for more info.










  • More from author
    -  Who Is Alexander Downer?
    -  Howard Government Wins Historic Fourth Term
    -  Ja Lang G.Greene Interview
    -  Gay Marriage and the Politics of Division
    -  Is a Madrid-Style Terror Bombing Possible in Australia?

    See news about
    There will be no page refresh, so check it out.
     
    As in the United States, Australians are embroiled in a debate over the rights of gays to marry.Unfortunately the debate - as is also the case in the U.S. - is politically motivated with the election in Australia due later this year. 

    With the Bush administration seeking to exploit the gay marriage debate for its own political advantage in the US Congress, it is hardly surprising to find Australian Prime Minister John Howard jumping on the anti-gay bandwagon for the same cynical purpose. As the Bush administration attempts to change the constitution to limit legal marriages to those between a man and a woman, in Australia an attempt by the government to launch a similar debate has begun with the Australian election due before the end of the year.

    In a classic display of wedge politics, the Howard government has proposed that the Marriage Act be amended to ban marriages between same-sex couples a situation that already exists, as gay marriage is not recognized under Australian federal law. As the proposed amendment only seeks to preserve the status quo, the ruling Liberal government has been accused of political cynicism by igniting the debate with the sole intention of dividing the Opposition Labor party on the issue.

    The proposal has caused outrage among many gay rights groups. According to Iain Clacher, editor of Queensland Pride newspaper, Australia needs to have real debate, not some cheap pre-election stunt. Gay advocate Rodney Croome said in an article in Bnews, In the past, conservative governments have tried to win political advantage in the lead up to an election by demonizing less than popular minorities and splitting their political opponents.

    The Australian Democrats, who along with the Greens are expected to vote against the issue in the Senate, have condemned the move with spokesman Senator Brian Greig accusing the government of being out of touch with the rest of the world on gay rights.

    "Political leaders in Canada, Spain, Belgium, the Netherlands and an increasing number of States in the USA are generating sensible debates about same-sex couples and their children, and passing equity laws to protect the best interests of those families.

    "By comparison, Australias leadership has been immature and reactionary. As a community we need to acknowledge the existence of same-sex relationships

    In a surprising and controversial move the Opposition Labor party, in an attempt to defuse the issue, has supported Howards proposed amendment. The move has caused dissent among Labor ranks though with left-wing backbenchers arguing the proposed amendment contradicts Labor party policy that no one should be discriminated against on the grounds of their sexuality. The dissenting backbenchers have said that it is political suicide for the Labor party to be seen to be backing down on its principles so close to the election. Recently elected Leader of the Opposition Mark Latham has found himself in the middle of a political minefield with the very real risk of alienating a significant number of voters whether his party supports the amendment or not precisely the outcome PM John Howard would have hoped for.

    Criticizing the Oppositions decision to support the amendment Greens Senator Kerry Nettle said, In trying to out 'Howard' Howard, Mr Latham appears to be willing to flirt with prejudice against the gay and lesbian community [he] has spoken of the importance of leadership in building community values, but he has failed in this instance to show leadership in dispelling discriminatory views regarding the lesbian and gay community.

    Latham, in an attempt to placate members of his left faction, has reiterated his call for bi-partisan support for the amendment but suggested a compromise plan where gay couples can be adopted from overseas. However Dr Carmen Lawrence, president of the party and de-facto leader of the left has dismissed the plan calling for her colleagues not to confuse politics and principles. Senator Bob Brown, Leader of the Greens has described the Labor partys proposal as homophobic.

    Political ploys such as these practiced by our major parties against members of minority communities run the very risk of alienating not just the minorities themselves but in a very real sense, progressive voters sympathetic to the communities cause. The eventual result may be the further drift of voter support away from the traditional parties to smaller fringe parties such as The Greens and the Australian Democrats. Unless the Liberal and Labor parties can see the electoral risk implicit in their cynical political point-scoring, Australian voters, already deeply cynical of politicians, will exercise their democratic right and register their disapproval at the politics of division.



    AUTHOR: Rich Bowden(UNV)

    TAGS: Opinion                                 

    BOOKMARK: Digg it  |  Add to Del.ICIO  |  Add to FARK  

    ACTIONS: Comment   Save   Print   Register free acount   



    xtof




    xtof says on 2004-08-23 20:52:59 about
    Politicians despise the gay community, considering the gay union as an elections stake! This subject is too serious to be treated that way...
    Shame on the politicians!






    gemma




    gemma says on 2004-08-22 02:53:39 about
    the poilitcal games are disgusting, and these politians should consider what effects they are having on individuals rather that the voting masses. great article.






    Brian Hokanson




    Brian Hokanson says on 2004-08-20 03:25:25 about
    Thanks for the in-depth account of the situation down there.









    Post Comment

     
     Your nickname
     
     About what
     
     Your comment
     




    ADVERTISEMENTS
    Anxiety - Anxiety, Depression and ADHD related information.


    DUI Lawyer - find the right attorney nationwide | vasectomy reversal - Dr. Schows success rate for restoring more than 1 million motile sperm to the ejaculate is 95% based on data from the last 500 vasectomy reversals performed at MMHC. | Convert 8mm Film to DVD | Comcast promotional offers - . | legal credit repair | Staff Leasing Company - | Steel Building | Frigidaire parts

    The Cheers magazine: About us | Contact us | The Cheers Story | Advertising
    Work with The Cheers: Writers guide | Write for us | Writer application | Reporter application | Affiliates
    The Cheers feeds: Free article feeds | Free news feeds
    The Cheers: Brand Lady (sister magazine) | Terms and conditions | Privacy policy | Sponsoring | Sitemap
    Watch: Watch movies online | Watch free tv online | Watch heroes online
    Trade: Virtual stock market | Fantasy investing competitions | Free day trading tips
    Learn: Business videos online | Business networking | Business strategies | Business ideas
      Write for us:  Become a writer    Become a reporter Latest news: New Book Published