Thank you for reading thecheers.org's Opinion articles.

Article by



Australia - Land of the Free?
Reece Pocock short Bio. I live in Adelaide South Australia with my wife Marilyn who is the guiding light in my life. My son lives not far away with his wife and three gorgeous Granddaughters that are the joy of my life. "After many years of working, having a family, community and military service, I thought I had a story to tell, so I wrote a novel. The trouble was, when I read it, I knew it wasn't good enough. The professional writing course at Adelaide Centre for the ARTS proved to be ideal for me. The four years I spent studying opened up many opportunities and proved life changing. "I am currently employed as a finance broker and find as much time to write as I can." Current work in progress The historical novel that started it all is under consideration by a US Agent. Iím trying to find a producer for two film scripts. I am also working on another novel, children's stories, and short stories. And I am writing articles for a trade magazine as well as TheCheers. Specific Skills and Work Orientation Much of my work is history based with particular interest in the Australian Military. I am interested in commission or freelance work of all kinds, and willing to discuss any proposals. I enjoy research, and have good computer skills. Memberships SA Writer's Centre since 1998 Grace Emily Writer's Group Australian Writerís Guild

In this article Reece discusses bow to queen.


Why Bow to the Queen?

 article about bow to queen
2008-04-22 03:20:57

This article belongs to Australia - Land of the Free? column.


In a recent visit to Queen Elizabeth 11 the Australian Prime Minister, Kevin Rudd nodded slightly instead of the traditional head bow on meeting the Queen of England. Back in Australia there was some debate that the PM didn't show proper respect to the Monarch.

For those doubters let me state the protocol taken from the Ceremonial and Canadian Symbols website.

It is up to those meeting the The Queen, The Duke of Edinburgh and other members of the Royal Family to choose whether or not they wish to bow/curtsy or simply to shake hands.

Description of a bow/curtsy for those who choose to make it:
Men: a neck bow - just a little more than a nod of the head;
Women: the right foot is placed behind the left heel, and the knees bent slightly.

It is quite in order to shake hands if the opportunity presents itself and a member of the Royal Family offers to do so.


For those Australians accustomed to the exaggerated bow by the former Prime Minister John Howard, Rudd's nod was seen as inappropriate. What would you expect from someone who supports an Australian Republic was the sentiment?

Any bow by Rudd should be interpreted as not appropriate. The Prime Minister of Australia should not bow to any other head of state.
 article about bow to queen
It could be interpreted, as Australia is subservient to England unless the Queen bowed back to the Prime Minister.

But, all of this protocol is complicated by the ludicrous situation of The Queen also being The Head of State of Australia. However, there is no doubt she favours England and it has been the case at trade shows and sporting conflicts where the Australian Head of State has promoted England - where she is also the Head of State - over the interests of other nations including Australia.

The Japanese use the bow as a greeting and a mark of respect but they bow to each other so there is no suggestion of subservience. Although in some situations the size or method of the bow may suggest the same as bowing to a British Monarch.

The curtsy is even more exaggerated and the protocol here suggests it is not necessary.

The British still have the remnants of their rigid class system in their society so to suggest to them not to bow or curtsy to The Queen would seem like blasphemy and unfortunately that is true of some Australians.

So Kevin Rudd's gesture may have been aimed at that part of Australian society that still sees the Queen as central to their feelings for the Monarchy. For them the Queen is seen as a symbol of stability and more than any politician or appointed head of state could offer. She represents morality and longevity and they embrace the Monarchy for much more than the Queen's roll in Government.

It boils down this, to if you are representing yourself in front of the Queen then you can bow/curtsy if that is what you want to do, but in an audience on behalf of a country then care must be taken to make sure the gesture is appropriate.

What would you do? Personally I think a handshake shows a mark of respect and is appropriate like I would with any one else. Not that I could imagine the meeting ever taking place.




have your say


more in Opinion
AMERICA, CAN WE CHOOSE WISELY?

IT IS NOT ABOUT OBAMA, CLINTON OR MCLAIN. IT IS ABOUT THE AMERICAN PEOPLE TAKING CONTROL OF OUR FUTURE.

The impact of paradigm changing events on legal systems

How the codified British legal system was born out of prosecutions of the Thugs in India.

Is Bindi Irwin Exploited?

Bindi's future is already planned for her and she is convinced that is what she wants to do. But the question has to be asked are those around her influencing her because she brings such great publicity to the Steve Irwin juggernaut.

The PayPal Challenge!

What does paypal have to do with banking? Southern Electric and The Sun newspaper are awarded The Guinness World Record(tm) for their groundbreaking campaign

Do You Have to be Poor to Succeed?

Somewhere in them was a spirit that was ignited by their circumstances that made them fight for every opportunity. Once they had that break they made the best of it. Maybe that's all it takes - make the best of every chance you get.

thecheers.org

Welcome to TheCheers! We've been around for a long time now, since 2004, publishing articles by people from all over the world. Roughly 300 people from 30 different countries have written for us over the years. Should you want to become a volunteer contributor, be sure to contact us!

Educational resources
Entertainment Blogs
get in touch

You can contact us via The Cheers Facebook page or The Cheers NEW Twitter account.