Who gave doctors and pharmacists the right to make reproductive choices for women? Obviously they did it themselves, when they began refusing to prescribe or dispense prescriptions for birth control pills, and other hormonal contraceptives, claiming moral or religious beliefs as the reason.
Several stories of women being denied birth control pills by doctors and pharmacists have made news headlines and are sparking more than a little controversy. Many pro-choice advocates, myself included, believe health care professionals, whether they work in a doctors office or a pharmacy, do not have the right to deny contraception to women based on personal beliefs. Doctors and pharmacists on the pro-life side argue that they should not be forced or required to give patients or customers a medication or product that they feel "ends a potential life."
The concern for pro-choice advocates is whether such a reason is truly legitimate or whether it is an attempt by the Religious Right to make it more difficult for women, particularly unmarried young women, to obtain hormonal contraception. Since the Pill, the new skin Patch, and the vaginal ring generally have higher success percentages for preventing pregnancy than the "faith based" methods like Natural Family Planning, supported by the Catholic Church, one has to wonder. Especially since the conservative religions like Catholicism have long been opposed to most forms of contraception.
Although most pro-life groups only target abortion rights to be made illegal, and have been doing so since Roe V. Wade was decided in 1973, there are some ultra-right groups that would like to see all forms of contraception legally banned as well. These groups include Quiverfull, an ultra-conservative Christian sect that opposes even voluntary sterilization, believing that all sex activity should come with the "responsibility" of pregnancy, childbirth and parenthood, and that sex should not be indulged in for the solitary purpose of pleasure.
But Quiverfull is not the only group that opposes contraception. The American Family Association, headed by Rev. Mark H. Creech, is another. In an article that appeared in the AFA Publication Agape Press News, Creech ended his diatribe against abortion and birth control with the following statements:
[BB]
"Let it suffice to say contraception and abortion are the twin-children of a Medusa-like god with vipers on her head that represent a self-centered, anti-child, materialistic, non-theistic quality-of-life mentality that God will not indefinitely suffer as a rival.
I believe Matt Trewhella, pastor of Mercy Seat Christian Church in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, aptly summarized the argument: "We have no God-given right to manipulate God's design for marriage by using birth control. As long as we continue to make 'possessions' and 'self' our god, and as long as we continue to look at children as a diaper bill rather than a blessing, we will never see the Church act in mass against baby-murder."
How Rev. Creech equates contraception with "baby murder" is anyones guess, since responsible use of contraception prevents pregnancy, and by extension, abortion. But it doesnt take a genius to see that the Rev. Creechs agenda is to get rid of contraception altogether, since he and Rev. Trewhella believe it "manipulates Gods design for marriage." Which, in their opinion, seems to focus solely on procreation. What he and other evangelical Christians continuously fail to acknowledge, however, is that the United States is a secular country, and is not dominated by Christianity or any other religion. Which means that not every American citizen shares his anti-contraception beliefs, and should not be denied contraceptive methods simply because he or any other Religious Right leader opposes them.
With both sides not giving an inch of ground, one has to ask if there is any "right" answer to this dilemma. Both sides of the contraception issue believe theirs is the right one, which leaves everyone with the proverbial stalemate. However, there is a way to help avoid situations where a woman is denied contraception by her regular pharmacist and is forced to seek another who will give her the birth control method she wants. Ironically, it isPharmacists For Life International that has provided such an alternative; a list of "Pro Life" Pharmacies. At the present time, it is a short one. Anyone who wants to get their prescriptions for oral or other hormonal contraceptives filled only has to visit the P.F.L.I. web site to know which drug stores not to patronize.
Of course, the critics will no doubt have plenty to say about attempts by pro-choice consumers to boycott pro-life pharmacies. Whatever verbal ammunition they have in response, I say bring it on. If Pharmacists For Life insists on maintaining their right to refuse contraception to women based on their moral or religious beliefs, we can exercise our right to refuse doing business with them. But honestly, I fail to see what theyd have to complain about. Knowing which pharmacies are pro-life saves women the hassle of making a wasted trip to an establishment that refuses to provide the contraceptives they want, and saves pharmacies on the list from being on the receiving end of many angry complaints. A win-win situation if I ever saw one.
Factzone: The truth about Kim Jong Il Kim Jong Il, the leader of the free world, has decided to move on to more fertile grounds, leaving with us just the memories of 8-color rainbows, singing Korean women and couple of nuclear weapons. But who was this man whose next ambition would have been to get the next Nobel Peace prize? Here are just a few facts you should know about.
World governments charged with criminal negligence (in response to Megaupload case) EARTH (thecheers.org) - Federal authorities of the universe have charged the governments of all the countries in the world as well as the operators actually in power in these countries with operating a criminal enterprise, the Galaxy warriors announced Today.
USA says on 2012-02-12 01:24:35 about eLvjLyvdiNzsallra
WM7w5l The topic is pretty complicated for a beginner!...
S. Cathcart says on 2005-02-21 19:24:07 about What a comical assertion!
A commenter who chose to remain anonymous opined: Actually, America is not a secular country, no matter how much you would like it to be. Frankly, our constitution just doesn't work if it is not lined up with the Christian ideals held by the founding fathers. We are a constitutional republic, and our founding fathers didn't even believe you could call yourself an American if you didn't believe in God. So morals have a place everywhere in this country, especially in government AND healthcare.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Your ignorance is pretty appalling, sir/madam. First of all, the US Constitution is based on English common law. No less a person than Thomas Jefferson specified, in the Treaty of Tripoli, that the US is *not* founded in any way on Christian principles, as it is understood that this is a nation of immigrants. Furthermore, the majority of the so-called Founding Fathers were secular deists and not Christian at all. They believed in a Creator, but not a Christian god.
Finally, who are you to dictate morality to anyone but yourself? Why are your personal ideals applicable to me in the slightest?
Mar says on 2005-01-02 11:52:30 about America
Actually, America is not a secular country, no matter how much you would like it to be. Frankly, our constitution just doesn't work if it is not lined up with the Christian ideals held by the founding fathers. We are a constitutional republic, and our founding fathers didn't even believe you could call yourself an American if you didn't believe in God. So morals have a place everywhere in this country, especially in government AND healthcare.
Lily says on 2004-11-23 22:59:42 about
Interestingly, my experience with this was a bit different. I have an Osteopath instead of a regular medical doctor. About the time in my life when I was first considering sex with someone, I went to her complaining of stomach cramps and three minutes into a five minute appointment, she was writing out a prescription for birth control for me!
I was somewhat upset that she hadn't even examined me or given me other alternatives, specially since my mum is one of those conspiracy buffs and she has ingrained in me that widespread consumption of birth control and flu shots are govt test expers, haha...
But then my boyfriend looked at the prescription and was quite thrilled by it!
Brenda says on 2004-11-22 19:20:07 about I agree with you
I have to agree with you on this, Susan. Women should not have to be subjected to the moral beliefs of the doctor or pharamcist for birth control. I've always believed that it is a woman's right to do with her reproductive body as she sees fit. I disagree with Nemesis that doctor's a pharmacists are not obligated to prescribe birth control. They are a public entity of sorts, and are therefore obligated to perform a public service, leaving their personal moral beliefs out of it. It's that simple.
Nemesis says on 2004-11-22 16:13:58 about your nonsense again
A birth control pill is not a medication. It's not something a doctor has to prescribe to make you well. It's something you CHOOSE to take. With that in mind, it's not something a Doctor should be compelled to give you if he/she has issues with it. I personally don't care. But to attack Doctors because they don't want to give someone a pill that does nothing to make them feel better from an illness then that's their choice. They don't hand out heroin either. You act like it's a crisis, like the whole birth control world is going to disappear, PLEASE STOP WITH THE SCARE TACTICS. There's plenty of doctor's who prescribe them, plenty of people who won't allow the clock to be turned back to a time when it was illegal for a woman to have a child vacuumed from her insides either. Last time I checked, the other side (the Christians and Right Wingers) has a right to persuade lawmakers too. Your side is just a ridiculous as theirs. Maybe you should all just hump each other for awhile.
DSE is the world's largest international trade show and conference dedicated to digital signage, interactive technology and digital out-of-home networks and it will be taking place from March 6 to March 9, 2012.
Argonaut Genre:Alternative The band are led by Core Members, Lorna (Vocals & Synths) an...
The Kut Genre:Alternative As three female musicians on the London circuit, questions l...
The Exits Genre:Electronic Genre: Electro / Indie / Rock
Location Portsmouth, South, U...
Trip Effect Genre:Rock A power trio that mashes up alternative/indie/rock with warm...
Jim Scordilis Genre:Rock jimscordilis@gmail.com
http://www.facebook.com/jimscordil...
Valadis Gaoutsis Genre:Rock Facebook Fan Page: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Valantis-G...