How to Survive a Writers' Critique Group

How to Survive a Writers’ Critique Group

All over the United States, and perhaps around the world, aspiring writers meet together for mutual support and development. Groups of would-be writers haunt the basement rooms of churches, family living rooms, and back rooms of restaurants. Since retiring from my career, writing has been my main activity, and I have spent hundreds of hours in writing critique groups.

Many writers reject discipline, and they can be a hard bunch to control. Without rules, however, a writers’ group is a great waste of time. Here are some suggested rules that work for me:

The maximum number of writers in a critique group seems to be about eight. In a two-hour meeting, this affords each writer about fifteen minutes, and that is not a lot of time.

Each meeting requires a group leader. This job rotates among the membership; having one dominate leader may not be a good idea for most groups.

If the group is at a limit of eight members, new members can form their own group or go on a waiting list. If there are many writers in an area, specialized groups may form around poetry, memoir, novels, etc. I think it is a mistake to extend the time of a meeting to accommodate more members.

The meeting must begin exactly on time and end after two hours. Why a time limit? The human brain can focus only so long on critical analysis, and the human butt can sit for only so long in one place.

If there are eight writers present, each member must limit their group time to fifteen minutes, and that is about 1,000 to 1,200 words.

“But I’m writing a novel and I must read a whole chapter,” protests one writer.

So, break your masterpiece into sections week after week, or just use the meeting as a place to display a limited work sample. It really is not so important that the group appreciate the whole project; that’s up to a potential agent or publisher. Without knowing the full plot or all the details the group can help at a specific level with character development, dialog, point-of-view, and so forth.

Those who read should always provide printed, double spaced copies to give to the group. These copies are returned to the writer at the end of the meeting with comments and corrections added.

The group begins with any news, announcements, or brags. One of the greatest moments in a writing group is a new writer reporting a first publication or contest win.

Each member, in turn, reads his/her material aloud, and members follow along in the printed manuscript. After reading, the writer must remain silent while members take turns, one at a time, making their comments. Cross talk, explaining, and defending must be delayed or even eliminated. When each member of the group has offered comments, then the writer may answer specific questions and add comments.

If you don’t want honest feedback, don’t read. Once you read, shut up and listen. Just listen to opinions and suggestions. Take what you can use, leave the rest, and be sure to say thanks. Never be defensive or argumentative. If your writing does not stand on its own, fix it and don’t bother people with explanations.

In commenting on the work of others, sandwich any negative criticisms in between positive, encouraging comments, but always be honest and unapologetic. Avoid any and all personal attacks and never become defensive yourself. Never argue over controversial content.

The group’s concern is the craft of writing. What a writer says is his or her business; the group’s job is to help each other say it effectively.

Beware the entertainer who is looking for an audience rather than a real critique on what he/she presents. This is a writing group, not a performance group.

Beware the scold who wants to inflict personal standards and preferences on everyone.

Beware the amateur poet who has no idea of meter, verse, modern poetry, style, or devices such as metaphor,

Beware the memoir with memories not worth keeping. Some people assume that they have had a very interesting life. There are, for example, millions of children of abusive alcoholics who think their story is unique and worth writing about. Sometimes, once in a while, that’s true in the hands of a good writer. At the other extreme, making cookies with Aunt Emma is probably boring for most readers.

Beware the victim seeking a therapy group. Always go back to the basic reason for having the group, and help those who need some other experience find the right place to be.

Beware the professorial type who wants to be a teacher and group leader.

To be a writer is to sit down alone for long periods every day and write. To be a writer is to submit, submit, and submit some more. If a writing group helps, stay with it, but don’t be afraid to walk away if it does not.


(Julian I. Taber, Ph.D. is author of Addictions Anonymous: Outgrowing Addiction with a Universal, Secular Program of Self-Development.
ISBN 978-1-60145-647-2.
To view the Table of Contents, sample chapters, or to order, go to: http://www.booklocker.com/books/3717.html)

Politics Factzone: The truth about Kim Jong Il Kim Jong Il, the leader of the free world, has decided to move on to more fertile grounds, leaving with us just the memories of 8-color rainbows, singing Korean women and couple of nuclear weapons. But who was this man whose next ambition would have been to get the next Nobel Peace prize? Here are just a few facts you should know about. more Top 5 Conspiracy Theories Related to John F. Kennedy's Assassination 26.Aug 2011 Since just after the assassination of John F. Kennedy, conspiracy theories abou...read ISRAEL KEEPING GHADDAFI AFLOAT 10.Mar 2011 ...read Glen Beck Is NOT the Anti-Christ! 10.Mar 2011 Hurtful and fiery rhetoric is now media’s default setting! This slippery and m...read Recipe for A REVOLUTION! (10 easy steps - try not to get burned!) 28.Feb 2011 Rebellion is cooking in the air. People are mad as hell, and not going to take...read THE ASSANGE CASE. CIA INTERFERED WITH SWEDISH LEGAL PROCESSES EXTREME RIGHT POLITICS A DANGER TO EUROPEAN UNITY THE AUSTRALIAN LABOR PARTY. OUT OF TOUCH, OUT OF FOCUS, OUT OF CREDIBILITY AND HOPEFULLY, OUT OF THE DOOR Opinion World governments charged with criminal negligence (in response to Megaupload case) EARTH (thecheers.org) - Federal authorities of the universe have charged the governments of all the countries in the world as well as the operators actually in power in these countries with operating a criminal enterprise, the Galaxy warriors announced Today. more The Great OSCARS 2011 – or so it would seem 5.Mar 2011 So, how exciting......a morning off, the Academy Awards. I wish I could say the...read Top 7 Expensive Bordellos. Prostitution: Shakedown, Tier Down, and Priced Out 31.Jan 2011 According to a report of the Washington DC-based US Department of State, The Ph...read The Great Secret and Reason for the JFK Assassination 11.Oct 2010 The great question is why the great secret? On June 4 1963, President Kennedy s...read Don't Do it! The 3 Worst Times to Get Tattoos 4.Oct 2010 As a general rule, tattoos gotten after 2 am are a bad idea. But in a bigger pi...read

Travel Travel Warning 13 September 2010 - DO NOT TRAVEL TO IRAN 13.Sep 2010 TRAVELWISE has been watching the situation in Iran for some months in relation ...read more TRAVELWISE TRAVEL ADVISORY 5th June 2010. DO NOT TRAVEL TO ISRAEL. 5.Jun 2010 Given the recent incident whereby the Israeli intelligence agency, Mossad, used...read TRAVELWISE. 16 APRIL 2010. EUROPEAN TRAVEL ALTERNATIVES 16.Apr 2010 Travelwise issues the following advice in relation to cancelled flights to, fro...read TRAVELWISE 6 APRIL 2010. AUSTRALIAN AIR TRAVEL. THE BEST WAYS TO TRAVEL BY AIR IN AUSTRALIA. 5.Apr 2010 Regular readers might have seen and read the various advisory and no-fly notice...read TRAVELWISE 2 APRIL 2010. QANTAS. 2.Apr 2010 Some concerns have been raised in relation to some of the maintenance practices...read Sport No Payoff From the Playoffs $16.50 will Get Anyone in the Hall Mr McGwire Stupid Athlete Tricks Technology Think Big! Think the World's Largest International Trade Show Top 9 cool laptop accessories for laptop geeks Twittering: I'm not that interesting Cheers Jesus' Answering Machine Brown Couch or twelve midgets in the town square How To Be Happy Drugged Out Saturday Nights Muslim Decapitation: Bad, or Simply Misunderstood?